A Landscaping Company's $450K Commercial Auto Claim

A landscaping company in North Carolina operated a fleet of six trucks — three F-250s with trailers and three cargo vans. The company employed 18 workers across four crews serving residential and commercial properties.

The owner had purchased commercial auto insurance when the company started with two trucks, but hadn't updated the policy as the fleet grew. Three of the six vehicles were listed on the policy; the other three were covered under personal auto policies.

During morning rush hour, one of the crew trucks (an F-250 towing a loaded trailer) rear-ended a sedan on I-40. The sedan's driver suffered a herniated disc and whiplash requiring surgery. The sedan was totaled.

The total claim — medical expenses, lost wages, vehicle replacement, and pain and suffering — reached $450,000. The truck involved was one of the three on personal auto policies, which explicitly exclude commercial use. The personal insurer denied the claim entirely.

The owner faced $450K in personal liability, plus the risk of losing the truck (which was financed) and potential DOT violations for operating a commercial vehicle without proper insurance.

We consolidated all six vehicles under a single commercial auto policy with $1M CSL (combined single limit) per accident. We also added hired and non-owned auto coverage to protect against liability when employees use personal vehicles for work errands.

The new policy included trailer coverage (often excluded from basic commercial auto), uninsured/underinsured motorist coverage, and a medical payments provision that covers crew injuries regardless of fault.

Because we had moved all vehicles to the commercial policy before this accident occurred, the $450K claim was fully covered. The injured driver received fair compensation, and the landscaping company avoided any out-of-pocket costs beyond the $1,000 deductible.

Consolidating from three personal + one commercial policy to a single fleet policy actually saved the owner $1,800/year in total premiums while providing significantly better coverage.

Related Coverages